How to Control Restaurant Food Cost Without Raising Prices

Restaurant food cost management graphic featuring fresh ingredients and a food cost checklist with planning, cost control, and profit improvement strategies. Highlights how restaurant owners can control food costs without raising menu prices.

Restaurant food cost stays under control when general managers track it weekly, key inventory items are checked daily, and the menu is engineered for profit before it ever reaches the cafes. That is the approach Mike Stasko, President of Sunny Street Cafe, shared with host Roger Beaudoin on episode 512 of the Restaurant Rockstars podcast.

Sunny Street Cafe is a legacy family business with 22 locations and growing. Mike also explained how the company handles hiring, retention and marketing, and what it did when egg prices spiked.

Key Takeaways

  • Review food cost weekly and check key inventory items daily.
  • Give general managers the tools to compare ideal food cost with actual food cost.
  • Engineer menus and limited time offers (LTOs) for profit before they reach the stores.
  • Consider absorbing a short-term commodity spike instead of adding surcharges.
  • Feature profitable alternative items when one ingredient spikes.
  • Hire for personality, coachability and punctuality.
  • Have the general manager personally onboard every new hire.
  • Support your community consistently with local store marketing.

How Do You Keep Restaurant Food Cost Under Control?

Mike said his team looks at food cost weekly and watches key inventory items daily. Food cost, he said, is the most volatile thing the company deals with right now.

Give General Managers Ownership of the Numbers

General managers are given the power to run their cafes as their own. They understand their profit and loss statements (P&Ls) and know their ideal food cost versus their actual food cost.

Mike pointed to small details that move the number:

  • One missing case of hash browns
  • Waste during a period

Use an Inventory System Your Managers Can Work In

Sunny Street Cafe grew from spreadsheets and a purchase-based inventory system to the Restaurant365 inventory management system. Mike said that is why the company believes it has best in class food costs, at least in the breakfast and lunch category.

Engineer the Menu at the Top

The company takes the pressure off its managers by engineering the menu before it reaches the cafes. When the team designs the menu or LTOs, Mike said they ask three questions in order:

  • Is it delicious?
  • Can it be executed consistently?
  • Will it be profitable for the cafes?

If managers execute the menu, the results should flow through. Mike added that breakfast is a gentler category. Eggs and pancakes are very profitable items, and the concept has no real center of the plate protein.

What Did Sunny Street Cafe Do When Egg Prices Spiked?

Skip the Surcharge

Mike said many breakfast competitors added surcharges of 75 cents or a dollar on egg items. Sunny Street Cafe decided not to take pricing.

His reasoning was that eggs are a commodity that would level back out. The team would rather absorb the cost in the short term than pass it to guests and have them not come back.

Put Non-Egg LTOs Front and Center

The company moved non-egg LTOs to the front of the menu:

  • Chicken and waffles, which had just been rebooted
  • Shrimp and grits, which Mike said had really good margins and still delivered the breakfast and brunch experience

How Often Should You Review Menu Pricing?

Sunny Street Cafe reviews pricing on a set rhythm:

  • A deep menu dive twice a year
  • A fine-tooth comb review annually
  • Pricing taken once a year on its in-store menu

Track How Volatile Each Ingredient Is

The team tracks how volatile certain ingredients have been. Mike said that just because eggs went up does not mean you stop offering eggs. The goal is for categories to have a good food cost on a blended average, with no items that are out of whack.

Know Your Tough Items

He named corned beef hash as a tough item because beef prices keep rising and there is a threshold guests will pay.

How Do You Hire and Keep Great People?

Mike said retention is a big part of the company's success, and some employees have been with the cafes for more than 15 years. Consistent faces help build what he calls a Cheers vibe, where staff remember guests by name and order.

Recruit Through Many Channels

The team tries many sources for new people:

  • Team referrals
  • Long-term guests
  • People who work at the high schools the cafes support
  • Job boards

Hire for Personality, Not Experience

When interviewing, they do not require a set amount of experience. They lean toward personality, whether the person is coachable, and whether they are punctual. Mike said interview questions focus on those traits rather than whether someone has used a specific point of sale system.

Let the Schedule Work for You

Mike said back of house is trickier to hire than front of house. The breakfast and lunch schedule, roughly 6:30 to 2:30, helps because parents can be home when kids get off the bus, and people can hold a second job. He said turnover is better than the industry standard.

Have the General Manager Onboard Every New Hire

Onboarding changed too. General managers now block out time to sit down with every new hire, answer questions and set expectations. Mike said it is more work for managers, but they see the value, and the company believes it has reduced turnover.

Put the Right General Manager in Place

He also called the general manager the single greatest indicator of a restaurant's health and retention. The right person holds people accountable while showing empathy.

What Marketing Works for a Community Restaurant?

Mike said the company spends on baseline digital for brand awareness, but most of its marketing line is local store marketing.

  • Cafes say yes to nearly all requests from schools, civic groups, church groups and scout troops.
  • The best stores are the most plugged in within one to three miles.

Frequently Asked Questions

How often does Sunny Street Cafe check food cost?

Food cost is reviewed weekly. Mike Stasko said key inventory items are looked at daily, using the Restaurant365 inventory management system.

How does Sunny Street Cafe use technology?

Mike said the company moved to handheld devices for pay and order at the table about three or four years ago, which he called a boon. It uses AI on the back end to help finance and operations teams pull analytics faster, and nothing customer-facing yet.

How many LTO menus does Sunny Street Cafe run each year?

It runs three LTO menus per year. Mike said LTOs also serve as a testing ground, and chicken and waffles earned a permanent spot on the in-store menu after running through a couple of cycles.

About the Host

Roger is a restaurant entrepreneur with 25+ years of industry experience and the founder and host of Restaurant Rockstars, a trusted resource for owners who want to increase profits, streamline operations, and build thriving businesses. Through real-world strategies and conversations with industry leaders, he helps restaurant operators lead stronger teams, maximize profitability, and achieve lasting success.

Listen to or watch the full conversation with Mike Stasko on episode 512 of the Restaurant Rockstars podcast, How to Hold Menu Prices When Restaurant Food Costs Spike.

Next
Next

Restaurant SOPs Independents Can Steal From a Chain With 96% Retention